Schools of Thought

If a daee says that he loves and respects all 4 madhhabs. But in fiqh and usool al fiqh, does not follow any one of the four and do their own ijtihad. Is there any problem in this?

Schools of Thought

12 Aug

ANSWER: If you mean that he follows only his whims and desires and he comes up with weird opinions that are not part of the 4 schools of thought, such a person is deviant and he is ignorant. But if he is knowledgable yet he chooses only what goes along with the Quran and Sunnah […]

My Uncle tells me not to move my index finger during attahiyat because ghair muqallid people do that who don’t understand the hadeeths well. He also tells me don’t read hadeeths and Directly understand becoz it will cause confusion and tells to follow a mazhab than follow sunnat as I might go wrong since there are context behind it. Any Advice Sheik please?

Prayer, Schools of Thought

12 Jan

ANSWER: Don’t listen to him as he doesn’t know anything about Islam as he is a blind follower of what his schools of thought tells him. Real muslims follow what Allah and the Prophet salla allahu alaihi wa sallam say.

My question is that there were already 4 schools of thought then why some saudi scholars introduced a new one SALAFISM and also it didnt decrease the difference of opinion but it only increased the difference of opinion and it didnt helped much, now there 5 schools instead of 4. Is Salafism a legit school of thought?

Schools of Thought

18 Apr

ANSWER: These 4 schools of thought were not revealed from Allah! Allah told us to follow the Quran and Sunnah with the understanding of the 3 favorite generations. This is salafiya. Praise be to Allaah. Salafiyyah is to follow the way of the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) and his Companions, […]

Regarding the 4 imams who (may Allah have mercy on them) Who would you say was the most knowledgeable out of them generally speaking ?

Schools of Thought

04 Apr

ANSWER: There was no competition between them to determine that.

As a layman I should follow a particular madhab but what if it says pray witr like maghrib, should I follow it?

Schools of Thought

31 Mar

ANSWER: If you know the authentic hadith about an issue, you must follow it even if it goes against the madhab.

Imam abu hanifa had students that were very big like Imam Bukhari and Muslim and all other imams of major madhabs. Then why is his madhab sometimes wrong if he is the teacher of other great imams like Shafii and others and imam bukhari and Muslim are not?

Schools of Thought

23 Mar

ANSWER: Where do you get your knowledge from? Imam abu Haneefa had nothing to do with Imam Bukhari or Muslim as they were not even born when he died! He died in 150 Hijrah while Imam shafi’ee was born on the that same year!

Shaikh in subcontinent mostly all people follow the Madhab of Imam Abu Hanifa(May Allah have mercy on his soul),but they stick to it and not look QURAN and sunnah,even it goes against it,and people hardly find any person that follow Quran and sunnah,what should a layman do here,he go with what his laocal aalim tell him or if he find something opposite,is layman allow to contradict?

Schools of Thought, Sects

23 Jan

ANSWER: One must not stick to a particular madhab when there is an established sunnah for it. Follow the Sunnah.

Sheikh, watching your videos has enlightened me a lot, but as someone born in Hanafi environment, i have caught a lot of things that contradict with the Sunnahs of Prophet especially in how to pray, after i watched your prophet’s way of praying video, it seems Hanafi has quite a few differences, now what to follow and what not to?

Schools of Thought

07 Jan

ANSWER: Once you come to know the authentic sunnah about a particular issue you must follow it.

When I do something from other madhab, like reciting fatiha(quietely) being a muqtadiy, or raising hands before and after ruku they are sometimes very critical saying “in Hanafi madhab it is not permissable. If you’re from this madhab you should do everything according to it, and not pick and choose. Should I not do them even if hadiths are authentic, not to cause fitna?

Schools of Thought

06 May

ANSWER: It is not necessary to stick to a particular madhab, especially when we have an established Sunnah for it. Follow the Sunnah and ignore others who are ignorant and don’t follow the sunnah.

Is the reason that hanafi madhab has some weak hadith that the ahadith werent compiled yet completely or something else?

Schools of Thought

16 Jun

ANSWER: Yes, the hadiths were still not complied during the times of Imam Abu Hanifa, may Allah have mercy on his soul and not all of this followers had knowledge in hadeeth and how to segregate the weak from the Saheeh.

More..