pls if yes bring some points that i can tell to my sisters who belive that this is good practice.
I hear that hadith from abu musa (the story with ibn masaud) is inauthentic is that true?

…………………………………………….

The hadeeth of Abu Musa is authentic and it was authenticated by Imam Al Albani.

As for making Thikr in congregation, if this is only for the purpose of memorizing it and it is not related to after the 5 daily prayers and it is only until one memorizes it, this is permissible.

Otherwise, it is an innovation

Sheikh,we use in the masjed to make dhikr in congragation.Becouse we dont know to supplicate and make dhikr ,we folow the imam and somtimes we say it in unison.Is this bidah.

Innovations |