Sheikh, the hadith of ibn khuzaymah on prophet SAW tying his hands on the chest which is hasan as stated in islamqa but darul uloom fatwa member in my place in india told me that the hadith is daeef becoz the isnaad muammal bin ismail is munkaral hadith stated by imam al bukhari they have evidence for it. Is this right and is there any other authetic hadith on where to tie the hand.
Sheikh, the hadith of ibn khuzaymah on prophet SAW tying his hands on the chest which is hasan as stated in islamqa but darul uloom fatwa member in my place in india told me that the hadith is daeef becoz the isnaad muammal bin ismail is munkaral hadith stated by imam al bukhari they have evidence for it. Is this right and is there any other authetic hadith on where to tie the hand.
08Jun
ANSWER:
Is this the last issue that Muslims have left and would be united after it? If you don’t want to put it on your chest, then don’t!
Those who say it is not authentic, they themselves fail to produce one authentic hadeeth to prove that it is to be placed under the navel!
Sheikh, the hadith of ibn khuzaymah on prophet SAW tying his hands on the chest which is hasan as stated in islamqa but darul uloom fatwa member in my place in india told me that the hadith is daeef becoz the isnaad muammal bin ismail is munkaral hadith stated by imam al bukhari they have evidence for it. Is this right and is there any other authetic hadith on where to tie the hand.