ANSWER:

There is no contradiction. 

The one who was killed was actually fighting to kill as well and not only contemplating! 

One hadith says the one who was surely about to commit murder was killed by the other guy before he could do it but still he will be punished for his intention even if he Couldn’t murder.Another hadith says if we have a bad intention but do not act upon it then a good deed will be written for us for not doing the bad deed…Isn’t this a contradiction? Can u kindly explain plz

Commentary on Hadeeth | July 29, 2021 2:48 am
Previous

The hadith of Ibn Majah- Allah loves the strong believer than the weak ones…does strong here refers to strong in terms of phyiscal health or strong in terms of imaan and faith?
Next

If no sutrah is there and if a woman or black dog or donkey passes infront of a man,that breaks the prayer,but what if the woman passes from a distance (with no sutrah) that is greater than the place where he prostrates? Is the prayer still broken?