Home
Hadeeth & its Sciences
I told him you can’t use logic in Islam, he told me Quran says “Do they not think” “Do they not use their intelligence” and whatever hadith goes against the Quran he will reject because he using his logic. Says Saheeh hadith are not 100 percent authentic and some other person may come and make them daef after. Reufation for this?

I told him you can’t use logic in Islam, he told me Quran says “Do they not think” “Do they not use their intelligence” and whatever hadith goes against the Quran he will reject because he using his logic. Says Saheeh hadith are not 100 percent authentic and some other person may come and make them daef after. Reufation for this?

26 Mar

ANSWER:

Doubting the hadeeth is the first step to rejecting it! Allah stated in the Quran that He will preserve and protect the Thikr which is the Quran and sunnah. He also ordered us to obey Him and the Prophet salla Allahu Alaihi wa Sallam.

Insinuating that the hadeeth is not 100% authentic or accurate opens the door for rejecting all Hadeeths that we don’t like or goes against our desires and this is the way of people of innovation.

Avoid this person as he is a bad news!

Hadeeth & its Sciences | March 26, 2019 10:56 pm

Can you tell a da’if (weak) or Maudu (fabricated, forged) Hadith just for the purpose of virtue or to motivate a person?

How to respond to those who say that a da’eef hadith reported 3 times in books of hadith makes it a sahih/hasn hadith, thus making it acceptable to be used for islamic rulings, as many people here in Pakistan use it to justify bi’dah!!!

More..