1 and 2.

The answer is that this wish is permissible because it is only a wish.

3.On the other hand is generally OK because the majority of the people don’t say that out of doubt as this would be wrong and forbidden.

Can you please tell me weather the following sayings will make a muslim a kaafir? 1.saying “i wish ALLAH had made me a prophet/messenger” 2.i wish i had been one of the companions of the prophet. 3.when a person asks “are you a muslim ” replying “insha Allah i am a muslim”

Manners | February 12, 2014 5:03 am
Previous

Shaykh we know the fact that we SHOULD NOT take back a gift once we have given that to a person as there is a hadeeth about it as far as I remember But what if someone gave us a gift but after sometime we return that? Not with any bad feelings, just stating that I cannot keep it with myself.
Next

Shaykh, if a man is living in a non-muslim contry and is the only son living with his parents. And he does not desire that anyone else do any job, rather he has left his education so that he may be able to financial provide his old parents But the problem is that the job he got is at a hindu’s place. He did ask his boss if he can take small breaks for salah but boss explicitly rejected. What should the guy do? If he gets emotional and suddenly leaves his job then he doesn’t know when will he get another job as he isn’t much educated and he is the one who is suppose to provide to his old parents. What should he do?