ANSWER:

Yes.

QUESTION: When it comes to the hadith of eating 1/3rd of ones stomach. There’s other hadiths like when abu hurayrah brought people and they drank milk at the prophet’s home, which through his miracle was endless and drank till they were full, how do we reconcile between them? Does this mean that to eat 1/3rd is recommended, but to eat till full is makruh?

Commentary on Hadeeth, Halal/Haram Matters |