ANSWER:

They are both sinful for this haram relationship and will be both accountable for it. She must sincerely repent to Allah while showing deep remorse for this haram relationship.

QUESTION: If someone is in a Haram relationship, still if the guy hurts the girl very badly and breaks her heart and leaves her days after telling her he wants to get engaged to her, he will be accountable to Allah or no because it’s just a Haram relationship?

Pre-Marital Relations | June 10, 2025 10:53 pm
Previous

QUESTION: I was in a relationship with someone, but now I want to end it. However, the person is very sensitive and says they will commit su*c*de if I leave. To avoid a direct confrontation, I have gradually distanced myself, and now we have no real connection. However, they still believe we are in a relationship. From an Islamic perspective, will I be sinful in this situation?
Next

QUESTION: I ended a haram relationship with the intention of halal. I promised to marry her if Allah wills, but I found she’s still connected to non-mahrams in social media she claimed to cut ties with. I did istikhara but feel confused. Should I speak to her or stay silent, taking it as a test from Allah? I’m torn between keeping my promise and doubts about her honesty.