ANSWER:

You need two expiations.

QUESTION: I swore by Allah that I would stay away from a sin for a set period of time, but I broke it. A few months later, I made the same oath for the same sin but for a different time and broke that too. So do I need 2 separate expiations or just 1 because it is the same oath?

Oaths | July 22, 2026 11:49 pm
Previous

QUESTION: If someone committed zina and later told Allah that he would block pornographic websites, hoping this would increase his chances of forgiveness. Later, he changed his mind and did not do so. Would any kaffarah be required? He did not intend to make a vow (nadhr), pledge, or binding promise; he only said this while speaking to Allah.